Mealy Pie Crust

Perhaps one of the best things Travis learned in his first pastry class (at least my favorite trick) is that if you want chef-quality pies, you should make a different type of crust for the bottom and top crust of pies, particularly if you are putting in a wet unbaked filling, like with a custard pie. This mealy crust makes a beautiful, slightly cookie-like bottom crust that performs well when used with wet doughs and still makes a nice crust edge.

Time: 1 hour, plus chill time | Yield: 2 lbs of pie crust, enough for 4 (9 in.) bottom crusts, or 5–6 (9 in.) top crusts

  • 230 g pastry flour (or bread flour is fine)
  • 180 g butter (you can use as little as 150 and as much as 200)
  • 57 g water
  • 4.5 g salt
  • 11.5 g sugar (optional)
  1. Add flour, sugar, and salt to a mixer (we use a Kitchenaid-style mixer). Add butter in large chunks.
  2. Mix at lowest setting. Do not turn the mixer up higher, just be patient. You want to stop the mixer before the mixture becomes at all pasty but after most of the pieces are about pea size (it’s okay if a few somewhat larger pieces remain.)
  3. Add water to the flour slowly while mixing, until the mixture just comes together. There’s a chance you might not add all the water. Stop mixer as soon all the flour is moist—you really don’t want to over mix.
  4. Weight out into crust portions (see below) then make into patties and chill for 4 hours ideally, or if you’re short on time, just 2 hours will do.
  5. Roll out and par or blind bake before filling.

PS You can freeze the crust at any point, as dough, rolled out, par baked, or filled and baked as long as the filling freezes okay (apple pies, baked or unbaked, cream pies with stabilized whipped cream, pumpkin pies can all be frozen.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *