When I was researching these, we discussed whether a better name could be found because “no-bake” just seems rather generic. After a little googling, I found there are many circles in which they are called preacher cookies, which I find at least quite a bit more intriguing. This name is usually attributed to the fact that they are easy to prepare quickly (as might be necessary when a preacher unexpectedly visits) so just like funeral potatoes they gained their name from the most common situation in which they were found. I have resolved only to call them thus in the future, which means I’ll probably forget in five minutes, but it was fun while it lasted.
As far as the actual cookies go, I make these only every few years (usually because I forget they exist, then remember and miss them horribly) and by the time I get back to them usually can’t remember which recipe I use which has resulted in a lot of sub-par batches. Because these cookies are basically fudge, the method of cooking matters a lot to them turning out correctly. This recipe was adjusted from one at Cooking Classy which cleared up the confusion, clarifying the importance of boiling the mixture for just the right amount of time before adding the last few ingredients and they turned out beautifully.
Time: 30 minutes | Yield: Approximately 30 cookies
- 1/2 cup (113g) salted butter (or unsalted butter and 1/8 tsp salt)
- 1 3/4 cups (350g) granulated sugar (can substitute some with brown sugar)
- 1/3 cup (32g) unsweetened cocoa powder
- 1/2 cup (120ml) milk
- 1 tablespoon of cream (optional—if they overcook)
- 1 tsp vanilla extract
- 2/3 cup (160g) creamy peanut butter
- 3 cups (275g) quick oats (don’t use old fashioned oats)
- Set out a piece of parchment paper to drop them onto.
- Combine butter, sugar, cocoa, and milk in a saucepan over medium heat.
- Stir frequently until it reaches a full boil. Allow mixture to boil 60 seconds without stirring.
- Remove from head and add cream, vanilla, peanut butter and quick oats. Stir until combined (don’t take your time with this. They’re already starting to set!)
- Use a cookie scoop to drop them onto the parchment paper.
- Let set for about 20 minutes (or refrigerate to set quicker.)
PS I sometimes brown the butter before adding the rest of the ingredients. You can use crunchy peanut butter, add nuts or unsweetened coconut flakes (doing all three results in the cookies pictures above which we have dubbed “geode cookies.”) Like other peanut butter cookies, the recipes assumes you use a peanut butter spread, so they’ll be slightly less sweet if you used a no-added-sugar peanut butter. I say this is a plus because these definitely tend on the sweet side. I have to eat them with copious amounts of milk. Though given my love of milk, this provides very little obstacle.
PPS Also, Jaclyn from Cooking Classy warns that if they turn out too wet, they didn’t boil long enough; if they turn out dry, they boiled too long. I take them off a tad before a minute because I, myself, prefer a pretty soggy cookie over a dry one. If you think you overcooked them, add a tablespoon of cream to keep the final cookies from being too dry.
PPPS I have no idea why you don’t stir while it’s boiling. Is it like caramel and it will crystalize? More testing is needed. Update: I tried stirring. No crystallization but perhaps they are a little soggier. The boiling was significantly less dramatic with stirring.
